Silver costs 8,000 Coins, 5 Aquamarine Shards and 8 Red Jasper, and unlocks the Triassic work needed for Clara. Titanium costs 200,000 Coins, 20 Desert Topaz and 20 Jungle Emerald for the Panthalassa route. Pacific costs 350,000 Coins after Yara’s two hand-ins; the 12 October guide reports 1.6× Fossil Luck, 1.45× Coins per dig and 1.2× dig speed relative to Titanium.
The 8 October shovel ladder and later Pacific guide describe different dates. Pacific cannot dig Late Cretaceous in the later guide. Forgotten is placed above Pacific without a supplied recipe, price or exact stats. Basic Fishing Rod’s spoken 150 price comes from 6 October, with the currency label not restated. Spears are named for the cooperative Mosasaurus encounter, without damage values. Compare known Pacific multipliers.
The October 8 progression guide associates Wooden with Cambrian digging, Bronze with Devonian, Silver with Triassic, Iron with Jurassic and Titanium with Cretaceous. That is its dated five-tool subset. The later October 11 report adds an unnamed boss-drop shovel, and October 12 guides describe Pacific and rank Forgotten above it. Five is not the current global shovel count.
Goal
Known choice
Specific cost or limit
Clara’s Triassic rocks
Silver or better
Silver: 8,000 Coins, five Aquamarine, eight Red Jasper
PGG ranks it above Pacific, without its recipe, price or exact stats
For Clara, Silver’s recipe is a relevant tool choice rather than a complete flying pet by itself. For the sea route, Titanium enables the necessary rocks; Kai and Yara still need the ordered hand-ins. Pacific’s 1.60× Fossil Luck, 1.45× Coins per dig and 1.2× speed versus Titanium help compare its supplied attributes, while a Late Cretaceous objective remains outside its stated access.
Forgotten acquisition details
The October 12 Pacific article’s “second-best below Forgotten” comparison supplies a usable rank statement. It does not supply Forgotten’s purchase location, prerequisites, price, ingredients or exact stats. A complete obtain-and-compare answer therefore remains missing those specific details; no boss-drop alias or price is assigned from the separate unnamed new-shovel report.
A flight target has a different comparison
Clara’s guide calls Quetzalcoatlus fastest and rarest with a 5% egg award chance. Each repeat requires twenty Pufferfish, seventy Triassic rocks and 10,000 Coins. If you already own an Adult flyer and want transport, its known Partner/Summon route supplies that role without repeating the quest. A fastest-flyer source statement does not establish a full dinosaur Coin-income ranking.
For Clara’s Triassic work, buy Silver with 8,000 Coins, five Aquamarine and eight Jasper. For Panthalassa Sea Egg shards, prepare Titanium with 200,000 Coins, twenty Topaz and twenty Emerald. Pacific’s covered-island attributes cost 350,000 after Kai/Yara and exclude Late Cretaceous. PGG ranks Forgotten above Pacific without its acquisition or stats. These conditional choices do not turn an incomplete global tier list into a numerical income ranking.
Where do I find a higher shovel or spear recipe?
Known Silver/Titanium purchases are at Home’s Shovel Shop; Pacific is at Yara’s Shellsmithy after her hand-ins. The separate boss report supplies an unnamed small-chance new shovel, but no key recipe or exact odds; it is not a Forgotten alias. Spears are named for team Mosasaurus combat without a crafting blueprint, price or damage value. The full Forgotten obtain-and-compare task remains missing those actual fields.
How do I plan material farming efficiently?
Choose the actual target before collecting: Cambrian Aquamarine and Devonian Jasper for Silver, Triassic Topaz and Jurassic Emerald for Titanium. Subtract held stock with the material calculator; preserve food and next-egg reserves. A location map, PDF or world-layout query does not supply a new resource node or recipe: use the named islands and NPC route shown here.
Equipment list, listing order and locations
This listing contains 10 tools, with the exact Silver/Titanium/Pacific recipes and dated early shovel/rod statements. The cards show each entry’s useful collected fields, source/version conditions and real detail or next-step link. The listing order is a reference arrangement, not an income or rarity tier. Choose Silver for the stated Clara/Triassic gate, Titanium for Panthalassa shards and Pacific for its reported multipliers, keeping the 350,000 purchase and Late Cretaceous limit. The on-page listing is usable, but this build does not yet supply a separate downloadable PDF file.
To arrange your own choices by a stated goal, use the personal tier list maker. You choose the grades; the tool does not supply an official or stat-derived ordering.
Forgotten Shovel listing: what this reference contains
Forgotten Shovel: PGG’s 12 October guide places Forgotten above Pacific. Its price, recipe and exact stats are not given in that article.
Is Forgotten Shovel worth it? Best use and tier comparison
Forgotten is the source-stated higher choice in that one guide, so the comparison stays useful. Its actual price and stats are still missing, preventing a cost or return judgment for Forgotten itself. Pacific supplies a usable known budget and access limit; it is not silently declared better than the higher shovel.
Where to find Forgotten Shovel: location, map route and unlock requirements
The 12 October Pacific guide names Forgotten and places it above Pacific. It does not provide Forgotten’s location, recipe, purchase price or full unlock sequence. Pacific’s known alternative is Yara’s two hand-ins followed by 350,000 Coins.
Spears have a sourced cooperative-combat role. Their missing damage, cost and encounter reward values prevent a numeric best-weapon or payback ranking. Kai’s pointed Mosasaurus Skull quest is a separate objective and is not described as this fight’s verified drop.
Where to find Spears: location, map route and unlock requirements
The official description names spears for teaming up with other players against the giant Mosasaurus. It does not give the spear shop, unlock steps, price or damage.